Gaps and misconceptions in Plant genetic engineering in the context of Cardamine floral dip method

Photo by @Shraddha276

Why do we want to make transgenic Cardamine plant !?

Particularly An antibiotic resistant plant !?

How the mechanism of transgenic plant in plant tissue culture different from Floral dip method !!

Highlighted question during chatshaala,and still Cubists need Clarity in that !!!

These questions that also there in my mind when Chatshaala discussion end on 28/07/2023.

I became a part of CUBE in 2020 during the final year of my BSc Botany program.

During the First Online National Meet, I had the opportunity to witness my friend Arunima’s presentation on Cardamine.

Interestingly, it was the first time I encountered the term “plant model organism Arabidopsis” and I came to know about Cardamine ,an alternative of Arabidopsis.

Subsequently, through discussions in CUBE, I learned that Cardamine serves as a viable alternative to Arabidopsis, and Cubists are actively involved in developing transgenic Cardamine plants.

I’m studying Plant Tissue Culture as part of my syllabus, and the aspect that influence me the most is the ability to generate an entire plant from a tissue sample or any part of a plant. In the application process of tissue culture we are learning the genetic engineering Aspects .

When the Cardamine presentation was introduced, I attempted to relate it to what I had learned, but I don’t got the whole story of Floral dip method that Cubists are doing .

However, I realize now is the time for me to understand the aspects that aren’t entirely clear to me.

These are the Doubts that I had regarding Floral dip method in Cardamine !!

I asked this in Personaly to @Rechel_tirkey ,here are our conversations !!

An audio from me

[10/08, 7.25am] Rechel Tirkey CUBE:
Yes, Theertha . We can make resistant for other antibiotics as well. But for that we will need bacteria which will contain penicillin resistant gene or any other gene of interest.

That’s the application of genetic engineering. We use this technique to introduce gene of interest to other organism. So we can do that.

So, In our case, we had Agrobacterium with kanamycin resistant gene. So after floral dip experiment we consider that kanamycin resistant gene has been transferred.

An audio from me :

[10/08, 1:53 pm] Rechel Tirkey CUBE: Okay , so the objective of this whole experiment was to study genetic engineering and to understand it’s mechanism.

There must be potential use or application of making plant and animal antibiotic resistant. But here , By introducing Kanamycin resistant gene we are not exactly fulfilling any commercial or industrial purpose.

Let’s think in this way, by introducing kanamycin gene into Cardamine plant we are making it resistant for particular chemical i e kanamycin.

So, we can introduce such other useful gene by using the floral dip method.

For example- if I want to make a plant, draught resistant. I’ll transfer draught resistant gene into bacterial plasmid then perform floral dip method.

And I will expect that if floral dip method worked for kanamycin resistant gene then it will work for draught resistant gene as well.
[10/08, 1:54 pm] Rechel Tirkey CUBE: Hope, this explanation is helpful to you.

That was a very well explanation by @Rechel_tirkey ,Thank you :partying_face:

Back to My Understanding

Making Transgenic plants through Plant tissue culture

Plant material (embryo) in water with a few drops of detergent.

Explants (embryo) rinsed in deionised water.

Surface disinfect in 70% EtOH for 30 sec.

Explants (embryo) rinsed in deionised water.

I had tried a small attempt to germinate cardamine plants in Tissue culture Lab,Providence Women’s College ,Kozhikode.19/1/2022

But unfortunately i am not continued that ,Two seeds were germinated .

Coming back to our Topic;

After Isolating immature embryo transferring genes into plant cells by the Agrobacterium method (Agrobacterium tumefaciens carrying the gene of interest (resistance to the antibiotic Kanamycin)introduced to embryo)

Collecting transformed Embryo using Selectable marker

The seeds that grown in a medium that contains the antibiotic that will kill all untransformed tissues or cells. Therefore, only seeds whose cells have been transformed with the transgene construct survive in the presence of the antibiotic. The surviving tissue is removed from the antibiotic and allowed to regenerate into whole plants.

Why agrobacterium came in picture !!!

We are exploiting a natural phenomenon in Plant -Microbe interaction in Plant genetic engineering !?

Agrobacterium is a bacteria which cause crown gall diseases in Plants .How!!

1)Wounded plant cells exude general antimicrobial agents, such as the phenolic acetosyringone, which has no toxic effect
on Agrobacterium.

2)The T-DNA is excised and bound to VirD2(part of bacteria) protein.

3)The VirB protein forms a connection between Agrobacterium and the plant cell and facilitates T-DNA transfer into the plant.

4)The T-DNA is inserted into the plant cell’s genome.

WhatsApp Image 2023-08-18 at 12.28.16 AM

In plant genetic engineering, the Ti plasmid can be used to carry foreign genes into plant cells. The Ti plasmid is the disease-causing agent of the soil-borne bacteria Agrobacterium tumefaciens . When the bacteria infect a plant, a part of the Ti plasmid called the T DNA is transferred to a plant chromosome. When the T DNA is expressed as part of that chromosome, it causes the plant cell to divide and grow abnormally. Researchers have recently developed procedures for removing the tumor-causing genes from the T DNA and replacing them with desirable genes. The Ti plasmid containing the altered T DNA region can then be used to insert the desired genes into plant chromosomes.

Floral Dip method

Making kanamycin resistant Cardamine plants by Floral dip method

1)Seeds are Germinating and select the plant with floral bud

Floral bud of Cardamine dip in Agrobacterium tumefaciens solution contain kanamycin resistant gene .

Agrobacterium contain kanamycin resistant gene may incorporated to plant genome.

In this process, we just use detergent to loosen up the cell As the cell membranes are loosened up the desired gene will incorporated to genome of plant .

Selection of transformed seeds

2)Germinating seeds in Kanamycin solution

Those seeds which will germinate in Kanamycin solution will consider as transformed seeds and rests are non-transformed seeds.

In this process, we just use detergent to loosen up the cell As the cell membranes are loosened up the desired gene will incorporated to genome of plant .Please do comment @Rechel_tirkey @KiranKalakotiR @Shraddha276 @Arunan @Chitralekha &others

4 Likes

Gaps and misconceptions in understanding Plant genetic engineering:

: “Each cell produces only one spore and each spore, in turn, germinate into one vegetative cell. The spore is just a part of the life cycle of spore forming bacteria under unfavorable conditions. The spores are metabolically inactive dormant form for years but are able to form vegetative cells (one cell per spore) in the suitable environmental conditions.”
https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/immunology-and-microbiology/bacterial-spore#:~:text=Each%20cell%20produces,suitable%20environmental%20conditions.

[23/06, 10:13 pm] Theertha: THIS I NEVER KNEW EARLIER: (TINKE moment) for me . Thanks to @Dhanraj @Smiti &@⁨Chithra Ma’am⁩ others. The genes on the T-DNA have regulatory elements that are eukaryotic in nature, and hence cannot be expressed by the bacterium’s resident machinery. So the bacterium has to insert those genes into a plant cell to synthesize opines. https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/biochemistry-genetics-and-molecular-biology/agrobacterium-tumefaciens#:~:text=The%20genes%20on%20the%20T,plant%20cell%20to%20synthesize%20opines.

[24/06, 8:39 am] Batul Ma’am: TINKE Moment for me thanks to @⁨Chithra Ma’am⁩ In tissue culture technique lab to field takes a month and hence tissue culture is nor only expensive it is time consuming compared to floral dip method in Cardamine

Whiteboard screenshots of Chatshaala:23/06/2024 and follow up WhatsApp group discussions

[23/06, 2:47 pm] Dhanraj: How will you insert the gene?
[23/06, 6:09 pm] Smiti: Insert gene in cardamine? For that we will need a agrobacterium containing our gene of interest like kanamycin resistance gene. Then 2nd thing we need is cardamine containing floral buds. So we dip these buds in a cell suspension of agrobacterium containing Sugar (sucrose) solution ig and after dipping we wrap the buds with plastic and keep it for 24hrs… Then the bud will grow into flowers then seeds and these seeds will contain the gene. When we so a these seeds we get a plant which has our gene of interest in all its cells
[23/06, 6:13 pm] smiti: Not much prepared I think, we need to develop it and yes Yesterday I had a TINKE moment while discussing how BT cotton was made. I thought they might have created a cut/ wound on the stem and then infected it with agrobacterium but then I got to know about cell culture that was Used to develop BT cotton in lab
[23/06, 6:19 pm] Himanshu Joshi: How an agrobacterium carrying kannamycin resistance gene transfers it gene to the cardamine plant?
@⁨~Smiti⁩
[23/06, 6:20 pm] smiti: That is something even I am confused with… @⁨Himanshu Joshi⁩ sir
[23/06, 6:49 pm] Chithra Ma’am: Try to find answer to how Agrobacterium produces tumours in plants.
[23/06, 6:52 pm] smiti: Agrobacterium tumefaciens is a pathogenic bacterium that causes crown gall disease, a plant tumor affecting a wide range of plant species. Crown galls develop upon transfer of a portion of the tumor-inducing (Ti) plasmid, the transfer-DNA (T-DNA), into the genome of the bacterium’s plant hosts (Chilton et al., 1980).

Agrobacterium tumefaciens Promotes Tumor Induction by Modulating Pathogen Defense in Arabidopsis thaliana - PMC).
[23/06, 6:53 pm] Chithra Ma’am: Try to understand the process and write in your own words
[23/06, 6:54 pm] Chithra Ma’am: Tell us what you understood from the paper.
[23/06, 6:57 pm] Smiti : Agrobacterium has a gene that causes tumor. This gene in present in the plasmid i.e tumor inducing (Ti) plasmid… I think a part of Ti plasmid causing tumor is called T-DNA/transfer DNA.

So maybe agrobacterium might have some proteins to cut the gene and some protein like ligases that will stick the gene in plant genome…

But how will the agrobacterium enter the nucleus to reach to the genome of the plant cell?
[23/06, 7:00 pm] Chithra Ma’am: No thinking; be sure. Please search, read and understand the concept. Plenty of material available on the internet.

Following summary written by @Smiti

:sparkles: We started by Reading and understanding the acceptance letter, although we forgot to discuss what Peer reviews is. Then we tried to present the abstract as if it was actually been presented in AABE Conference. Then @⁨Batul Ma’am⁩ Ma’am asked when do we usually see cardamine cause recently we couldn’t spot it in summer since May. So @⁨Abhijeet CUBE⁩ suggested to wait till it rains.

:sparkles: According to @⁨Susanta Tanti CUBE⁩ sir he finds it difficult to find cardamine in his lab during Winters… Though I thought it was a winter plant. But @⁨Arunan sir :smiling_face:⁩ says it should be present throughout the year


:sparkles: Well back to abstract, the title says context to curriculum, how do we use cardamine as a context to understand our curriculum? Also is it even a part of our curriculum?

:sparkles: As a biotechnology student we studied genetics in 1st year. Recombinant DNA Technology in 2nd year and molecular diagnostic and bioinformatics in 3rd; which are part of genetic engineering and we can understand some part of it using Cardamine as a model systems.

:sparkles: Link what? It Can be rDNA (Recombinant DNA) Technology here we combine our gene of interest with genome of agrobacterium to insert it in Cardamine using gene transfer method called floral dip

:sparkles: While discussing how Recombination will take place in combination of 2 different DNA We had a few confusions related to genome of bacteria and

  1. how to transfer gene of interest from one bacteria to another
  2. How does Agrobacterium tumefaciens cause tumors in the plant?
  3. Does it really cause a tumor? If yes, then why??
  4. How does agrobacterium transfer it’s gene to the plant cell?
  5. Aren’t bacterial cell And plant cell totally different then how does plant cell accepts the gene past on by a bacteria?
    @⁨Amirtha CUBE⁩ ⁩ @⁨Kashyap Sapekhati⁩ @⁨~Biswayini Tudu⁩ @⁨~Dhanraj⁩ @⁨Theertha⁩ @⁨Shraddha⁩ @⁨Aditya Joshi⁩ @⁨Abhijeet CUBE⁩ @⁨Chithra Ma’am⁩ @⁨Susanta Tanti CUBE⁩ @⁨Himanshu Joshi⁩ @⁨Priti CUBE⁩ @⁨Nazish Cube⁩ and others